Whistleblowers Sound the Alarm to Fortify DC Ombudspeople for Children
Whistleblower allegations filed against the District of Columbia Child and Family Services Agency (CFSA) and the District of Columbia Public Schools (DCPS) highlight recurring patterns, revealing deep-rooted problems within Mayor Bowser's administration.
These issues have resulted in a breach of public trust while jeopardizing the welfare of vulnerable populations, particularly children. The prevailing culture within DCPS and CFSA agencies is marred by fear and intimidation, which has had severe repercussions on both DCPS and CFSA employees as well as the individuals they aim to assist - children and families.
The need for government agencies, particularly those involved in child welfare, to maintain integrity, transparency, and accountability cannot be emphasized enough.
One of the main topics raised in Christian Greene, former Ombudsperson CFSA, whistleblower lawsuit against the District of Columbia Child and Family Services is the alleged manipulation and downplaying of data within the agency. Specifically, Greene accused upper management of "whitewashing" a trend report that her office was responsible for publishing, thus concealing severe issues and compromising child safety.
These concerns brought forward by Greene are not isolated occurrences but rather indicative of a larger integrity crisis within the agency. The allegations made by Christian Greene shed light on a crucial problem present in CFSA, where decisions regarding child safety often prioritize liability over legal validity or children's well-being. Greene courage is highlighted in a 2019 Washington City Paper article: To Escape Court Oversight, D.C.’s Child Welfare System Is Cutting Corners
Furthermore, the whistleblower lawsuit initiated by Dr. Carolyn Jackson-King and Marlon Ray against the District of Columbia Public Schools unveils comparable apprehensions. These alarming worries encompass the implementation of unethical program practices mandated by the mayor, which disproportionately target disadvantaged Black students while granting exemptions to privileged White students. The deliberate harmful motives behind such practices have detrimental effects on Black children.
Dr. Jackson-King and Ray were fulfilling their legal duty as mandated reporters when they reported instances of harm inflicted on children. As mandated reporters, individuals who have close involvement with children are legally obliged to report any form of harm, including when it is caused by those in upper management positions of authority. By fulfilling this duty diligently, Dr. Jackson-King and Ray demonstrated their commitment towards safeguarding the well-being of vulnerable children. Their courage to speak up and protect children against the the agency has been readily discussed and written about nationally. Forbes
Greene, Jackson-King, and Ray all suffered serious retaliatory actions and were ultimately fired. While on the job, Ray even received an anonymous death threat. They openly discuss the prevailing climate within DCPS and CFSA organizations, which is characterized by fear, intimidation, and enforced silence that ultimately endangers the welfare of children.
These patterns of misconduct and negligence within DCPS and CFSA have led to a breach of public trust and a lack of confidence in the Bowser administration.
To tackle these repetitive trends and regain public confidence, the DC city council must strengthen current regulations and develop fresh legislation concerning child management. Such measures are essential for promoting efficient governance and protecting children's well-being.
To guarantee the rights of children, Greene’s whistleblowing resulted in significant steps towards implementing systemic reform through the enactment of the Office of the Ombudsperson for Children Establishment Act in 2020. However, despite facing certain obstacles such as mayoral veto that DC City Council overturned, and an emergency mayoral pulling of the Office’s budget, later restored by DC City Council the Office became live in 2021, it is evident that further transformative measures are still necessary.
A key component of this strategy involves establishing under the Office of Ombudsperson for Children:
1. an administration for all child facing agencies within the District,
2. appointing an expert in that field as the Ombuds (ex § 4–671.02 requires the Child
Welfare Ombuds to be a clinical social worker)
3. revamping the legislation for the the Ombudspeople for Schools, Department of
Behavioral Health, and
4. writing legislation for juvenile justice etc.
These endeavors will be governed by legislation and established protocols set forth by The United States Ombudsman Association model legislation and standards of practice: Independence, Impartiality and Fairness, Credibility of the Review Process, and Confidentiality.
Essentially, to establish a system of accountability and transparency in child welfare, education, mental health, health, and juvenile justice, it is crucial to implement an independent oversight mechanism as well as enhance the ombudspeople roles within CFSA and DCPS.
This approach would introduce checks and balances, ensuring that all actions taken by these agencies are continuously monitored. By doing so, any allegations of abuse or neglect can be thoroughly investigated while also safeguarding the rights of children under their care. The aim is to create a framework that promotes responsible decision-making and upholds high standards in child protection practices.
We possess the capacity to create what is best for our children in the District of Columbia.
In order to achieve success, persistent determination and unwavering dedication are crucial. Rather than solely focusing on policing families, it is essential to police oversight of the governmental agencies involved in protecting our most valuable resource: the children of the District of Columbia.
Comments